Functional approach in C#

Coming across this blog post about an inefficient C# code written somewhere and somewhen:

  for (int i = 0; i <= name.Length - 1; i++) {
String sTemp = "";

for (int j = 0; j <= name[i].Length - 1; j++)
if ("QWERTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNMqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm0123456789_".Contains(name[i][j]))
sTemp += name[i][j];

name[i] = sTemp;

The code meant to take a list of names and remove every not allowed character from them.

{"John Smith","Not-Allowed"} will become {"JohnSmith","NotAllowed"}

The blog post suggests to use regexp instead of character matching and to avoid new String creation.
However it seems to be a bigger problem that the code presented here is neither testable nor reusable and its structure is not protected against easy to make failures at places like:

  • for loop exit conditions: i <= name.Length - 1
  • accessing of array elements with indexes: name[i][j]
  • maintaining states like: sTemp += name[i][j]

But that makes it a good example for how to overcome these issues with a more functional approach.

The above code could easily be rewritten like this:

public List<String> simplifyNames(List<String> names) {
return names.Select(name => new String((name.Where(validChar)).ToArray())).ToList();
private bool validChar(char c) {
return "QWERTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNMqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm0123456789_".Contains(c);
Pardon my C#, I have never used this language before, so there might be more efficient ways for stuff like creating Strings.
Feel free to comment :-)

The main advantage of this approach is that it requires no states to be maintained, it is expressed using less code and additionally it has a well isolated space for the business logic (the valid characters).

See full example here.